Tuesday, 27 September 2011

Review: The Tale of Murasaki by Liza Dalby


Title:  The Tale of Murasaki
Author: Liza Dalby
Publisher/format: Vintage, Paperback
How I got this:  Bought in a Charity Shop

Synopsis (From Goodreads.com):

Liza Dalby's novel is a brilliantly imagined chronicle of the 11th-century Japanese writer Murasaki Shikibu. As we soon discover, our narrator has a good many doubts about the writing life. "As I pondered this question of how to be a success at court," she muses, "I came to the conclusion that literary ambition was more likely than not to bring a woman to a bad end." Happily, the real-life Murasaki persisted, and went on to become the author of the world's first novel, The Tale of Genji. For The Tale of Murasaki, Dalby draws on this groundbreaking masterpiece and on the surviving fragments of Murasaki's own diary and poetry, along with another masterpiece of the Heian period, The Pillow Book of Sei Shonagon. The result is a vivid and emotionally detailed portrait of an intelligent, sensitive, and complex woman.
In Dalby's novel, Murasaki writes her first stories about Prince Genji's amorous encounters in order to entertain her friends, and to express her own creative temperament. As the stories gain a wider public, however, they are transformed into a conduit for observations on the mores and intrigues of court life. And in the end, as the narrator struggles to stay true to her literary vision, her tales are inflected by Buddhist thought and become parables on the transience and beauty of the world:
I have always felt compelled to set down a vision of things I have heard and seen. Life itself has never been enough. It only became real for me when I fashioned it into stories. Yet, somehow, despite all I've written, the true nature of things I've tried to grasp in my fiction still manages to drift through the words and sit, like little piles of dust, between the lines.
Dalby is an anthropologist by trade, who has produced two previous nonfiction studies: Kimono and Geisha. And given that her research for Geisha gained her the distinction of being the only Westerner ever to have trained in that much misunderstood profession, it's no surprise that she is able to reconstruct 11th-century Japan with meticulous fidelity. It's all there--the political and sexual machinations, the preoccupations with clothing and custom, the difficult and tenuous position of courtiers, the intensity of female friendships in a male-dominated society--and the author shows us precisely how Murasaki's sensibilities were shaped by the culture in which she lived. This is a rich and convincing debut, and another chapter in the current resurrection of the historical novel. --Burhan Tufai

Review:

Firstly, I should point out that I’m really interested in Japan and Japanese culture, probably stemming from the fact that I studied Japanese from secondary school, and am currently semi fluent, despite having never been to the actual country myself.  I’ve read work by Dalby before, but previously only non-fiction. 

I found this book nestled in a local charity shop, and couldn’t resist.  I have to admit, I didn’t realize this was a fiction novel until I got it home and read the blurb properly.  That said, I was still interested.  Upon beginning to read, I was transported back to Heian era Japan, which was described in amazing detail.  It is obvious even to those not familiar with Dalby and her work that this work has been well researched, and the passion for this is obvious in the writing.  I was pleasantly surprised that Dalby is as good a storyteller as she is at giving non-fiction information. 

The writing in this book is beautiful, and the scenes described are done delicately and tangibly.  One of my only criticisms is that the character of Murasaki is somewhat distant.  You hear a lot of her descriptions of others, but you never really get a flavor of who she really is.  I think that's to do with the style of writing as much as anything else, but it would have been nice to have more than that. 

This really did appeal to me, and it was a nice escapist read, and I truly felt as though I’d been transported back to Heian era Japan.  It was very detailed, and enjoyable, though I wouldn’t exactly call it a casual read. 

I’d recommend this to anyone who has an interest in Japan on travel books, but I really wouldn’t call it a general read. 


Overall rating: 4/5
Writing: 4/5
Style: 5/5
Originality: 4/5
Characters: 3/5


0 comments:

Post a Comment